"Aaron" is not who you think!

03:35 AM

Ok, what do you all think of this: The baby in the flash forward "Aaron," is not Clarie's "Aaron" but that's what Kate, Jack and the other Oceanic 6 want the world to think. Why? Because the baby is actually the biological child of Kate and Ben. Yes, you heard me correctly. Kate and Ben.
Remember back when Sawyer, Jack and Kate were held captive by the Others? Well, there was that creepy scene when Ben made Kate put on a dress and then have dinner with him on the beach. When she was brought back to the cage where Sawyer was she was all brusied up and didn't want to talk about it. I think Ben raped Kate (perhaps in the same way he raped Rousseau...)
Now there has been all this talk between Sawyer and Kate of "I might be pregnant" - we'll perhaps she is, but it's not Sawyers but Ben's. That would explain why Jack doesn't want to see the baby. Kate names the child "Aaron" so Ben will think it's Clarie's "Aaron" and leave her alone and not kidnap the child like he did Rousseau's child.

I don't see Ben raping anyone.

WOOOOAAAHHH that would be nuts.... I woud'nt put nothing past him,it would explain why jack does'nt want to see him! very creative

I Think Ben could take Kate in a battle of wits because Ben is a superfortress of wit and Kate is practically unarmed...... but Kate would whip his bony but all over that island in a fistfight.

good point!!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by lockedown

I Think Ben could take Kate in a battle of wits because Ben is a superfortress of wit and Kate is practically unarmed...... but Kate would whip his bony but all over that island in a fistfight.

I too think in a fist fight Kate could take Ben, although there have been a few times on the island I don't think she was at her full potential.. Remember how she escapes the marshall at the bus/train station?? How well she did in the bank robbery.. On the island she has been in situations I thought she should have easily been able get out of that she did just give in..

As to the topic of this thread.. I highly doubt Ben raped, impregnated Kate and then didn't know and let her leave the island.. Just doesn't seem to fit to me..

remember what happens at when people get pregnant on the island. they die. Kate isn't dead yet. i believe she won't until the last season.
Something happens to claire. Its her baby.

My suggestion is that we open up a thread for all these off-the-wall theories to go under.. No offense, I don't mean anything rude or mean- I just think that some of the speculations are just fun for the sake of speculating. Especially if there's no plausible explanation going on.

I think the "Aaron" that Kate picks up at the end of eggtown is definitely Claire's Aaron.

I don't think Ben would physically rape anyone. It's not his style. He manipulates people. He gets them to do something he wants them to do and make them think it was their idea.

Just look at the way he has manipulated Jack and Locke. Pretty much everything Jack and Locke have done is what Ben wanted them to do.

No way. Ben is a little pansy. His method is mind control, not physical violence. Also, the show doesn't deal with really heavy stuff like that. I just don't see it happening.