"Aaron" is not who you think! - Page 3

i think the theory of Ben raping Kate is too out there, even for lost. i think the father of the child was that low life tom, claires ex, and i believe that something has happened to claire and kate is looking after the babies welfare, jack and claire find out about Christian being both their fathers, and jack cannot be with kate because he would be the "stand-in" father to a baby that he is already the uncle too. Jack cannot stand this as it reminds him so much of aarons mother, who evidently the magnificent 6 have left behind on the island of dreams... Christian sheppard or the psychic or claires must be in the running for Jacob...

Tom, I agree. In my opinion there are 2 reasons why Jack wouldn't want to see Kate's Aaron. 1) Like tom said Jack found out about being related to Claire and it's weird for him. 2) There was some course correcting time shift where Aaron is Kate's and Sawyers baby (i.e. Aaron was destined to be born but somehow was not born to Claire). The second theory was just something my friends and I were bouncing around, don't really have any proof.

In the trailir for this episode didn't it say that another member of the oceanic 6 would be revealed? Well the only new person we saw from that episode was Aaron and he was on the plane so wouldn't that have to mean it was Claire's Aaron? And there is this part in the episode where Claire has the baby and is with Kate and Kate gives the baby a wierd look. I think that was foreshadowing how Kate would eventually have to care for the baby herself. And lastley- Ben is too tight to rape anyone.

Quote:

Originally Posted by flaneuse

How two non-Caucasian parents are to come up with a blond child is beyond me.
How Sun would give away a child she & Jin longed for is another mystery, let alone the speculation that she would pull this off without letting Jin see the baby.
Occam's razor: "entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem" or as in English "entities should not be multiplied beyond necessity".

Hey flaneuse, think I remember that term "Occam's razor" from Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenence. True? Or were you a philospophy major?

Quote:

Originally Posted by CanO'Worms

Hey flaneuse, think I remember that term "Occam's razor" from Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenence. True? Or were you a philospophy major?

Dr.Lee, Ph.D.

Not a real theory. Someone trying to be funny.

As the author of the original theory I assure you that it WAS a real theory when I wrote it before I knew that "Aaron" was one of the Oceanic 6. Just because you don't agree please don't assume that it's not a real theory and that it is just "someone trying to be funny."

when kate picks up aaron is it just me or does aaron look a little big for a few month old baby? i cannot remember in that episode if they gave some kind date or reference in the flash forward.

Where did the "Ben rapes Russeau" idea come from? I believe Russeau and her husband came here and he got killed, she was already pregnant, or had had the child, I forget which, but the child was snatched up by Ben. Even as recently as the last aired episode, Ben says "even though you're not my biological daughter, they would use you against me. You need to go to the sanctuary."

Can anyone elaborate on this?

Thank you,

The Champ

The idea came from me not trusting Ben. He seems to lie a great deal and perhaps even "bring" people to the island. Probably not accurate but this is the "theory" page afterall : )