Ben's "MAN" on boat is NOT who you think it is... - Page 2

we`ll just have to wait and see i suppose.see who`s right and wrong....

I think Ben's man on the boat is....*drumroll, please!*...Ben himself. When Locke asks him to spill the beans, Ben says "OK, but you're going to want to sit down for this..." It's some kind of time traveling thing and the reason why Ben on the boat hasn't made any effort to go see Ben on the island and make sure he's ok is because they can't be in the same place at the same time or KABLOWEEE! like we saw with the bunnies. A cute clue to that was Ben's comment to Locke tonight about his dinner "Did this bunny used to have a number on it?"

How do you explain her death on the island?

Quote:

Originally Posted by pchee

a LOT of people have been saying that the "man" on the boat is michael but it's not. It's...LIBBY!

OK, granted...just a theory.

But hear me out. In "The Other Woman", Ben tells Locke to sit down before telling him who it is. Then in the promo for next week, it says that another of the oceanic six is revealed, and then there is a shot of someone holding a piece of paper that says "don't trust the captain" and then it says that we will see someone we never expected to see again.

I think Libby was Ben's "man" all along, getting des on the island, spying on hurley at the mental hospital and now, his man on the boat.

oh i posted after that ben digs her up and sends her out of the skiff with michael and walt and then she time lapses back to when she was alive.

it's a stupid theory i guess.

now, the thing with your theory...if the man on the boat is ben himself, wouldn't miles and his friends have seen him there?

I don't know if Michael being on the boat would be surprising enough for Ben to tell John that he needs to sit down. Ben knows that John has experienced the magical healing powers of the island not just once, but twice. They shared a Jacob experience. These guys are both chin deep in the island's mysticism. If Ben is telling John to sit, I think it's going to be something that would be surprising even to someone who would credit the island with miraculous abilities.

This is just a wag, but when that scene faded to black, I got a gut feeling that Ben himself was the man on the boat. I think it was the twinkle in Ben's eye that made me wonder: Who would be the last person John would expect? Perhaps the man John thought he'd been keeping as a prisoner?

I seriously think it is either Michael or Ben himself. This island isn't even reality to the rest of the world, so anyone that dies on the island is not "in reality" even dead. I also strongly believe that this whole thing has to do with time travel, appearing random places in different times or places which is why we keep seeing Walt pop up randomly and the therapist. So Ben is fully capable to be on the ship but I also think Michael is on there, because they told him to travel at the same points the whole time and that he would eventually find help. HELP- YEAH RIGHT!

Yeah! What she said!!! *pointing emphatically at Chrism*

Quote:

Originally Posted by chrism122

I seriously think it is either Michael or Ben himself. This island isn't even reality to the rest of the world, so anyone that dies on the island is not "in reality" even dead. I also strongly believe that this whole thing has to do with time travel, appearing random places in different times or places which is why we keep seeing Walt pop up randomly and the therapist. So Ben is fully capable to be on the ship but I also think Michael is on there, because they told him to travel at the same points the whole time and that he would eventually find help. HELP- YEAH RIGHT!

You might be on to something hope this is not a spolier, but i just seen the clips on dark ufo.Looks like a blonde woman jumping off the boat into the water.Or what if it is the helicpter chick.So many options it does hurt my head also!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by tursiops

I don't know if Michael being on the boat would be surprising enough for Ben to tell John that he needs to sit down. Ben knows that John has experienced the magical healing powers of the island not just once, but twice. They shared a Jacob experience. These guys are both chin deep in the island's mysticism. If Ben is telling John to sit, I think it's going to be something that would be surprising even to someone who would credit the island with miraculous abilities.

This is just a wag, but when that scene faded to black, I got a gut feeling that Ben himself was the man on the boat. I think it was the twinkle in Ben's eye that made me wonder: Who would be the last person John would expect? Perhaps the man John thought he'd been keeping as a prisoner?

I agree...mostly with the first part

Quote:

Originally Posted by daveoz

You might be on to something hope this is not a spolier, but i just seen the clips on dark ufo.

Spoiler for spoilerish:

So many options it does hurt my head also!!

it is a bit spoilerish, you might want to put tags on it