It's Official!!!!!!!!!!! - Page 3

02:19 PM

Oh but they did know who was on the plane, there was a manifest. That being if you believe Oceanic Airlines is a dharma front.

Quote:

Originally Posted by lostfan_snw6

why hadn't they just inserted Ethan's name on the manifest?
If Dharma was in on the crash, they'd have had to have gotten together with Oceanic Airlines, right? So they could have printed his name onto the manifest.

It's a very interesting point...I always assumed that Ethan Rom was posing as Nathan Rome...so they didnt know EXACTLY who was on the plane, they had some kind of foul-up where Nathan Rome became Ethan Rom....bad intel?

I don't have any hesitation about saying that Dharma brought the plane down. I think it would be rather foolish to assume anything to the contrary at this point. However, I am not so sure that they had as much control over the situation as some of the theories are giving them credit for. If Dharma had that much control, then they get an "F" in efficiency.

Scientists routinely work with a control set, and a variable set. Everything is very purpose driven. It just seems like there are a lot of variables that could have been made to go more in Dharma's favor, presuming they are as controlling as we give them credit for.

.....just playing the Devil's Advocate here.