True , and the real reason I don't trust Locke , is , ( like you ) I am a Charley fan . and that time Charley had that dream or hallucination (a lot like like he did with Boone and that plane ) , about Aaron being in danger and needed to be Baptised , Locke was totally out of line to treat Charley the way he did . Sure , Charley should not have taken AAron into the water , but he was ,in his mind doing what he thought was Right , And don't forget Echo suggested it and Claire did get Aaron baptised afterall. Point : a lot of them have had those odd dreams or hallucinations , and after all Charley did for Claire and Aaron including being hung only inches from his own death , and the fact that he is still clean from the heroin , should have earned him some respect . Don't forget too that Locke is the one who saved the heroin in the hatch in the end of that ordeal , Not Charley , what for ? ....... Plus throughout Charley's flashbacks he always returns to his strong Faith in God .... and is the only one if I recall correctly that has prayed ( with Rose ) for something that we know of ..... I know he helped Sawyer when they kidnapped Sun , but he is human too , and reallly just wanted Locke to pay some how ... anyway , as you can see I get into the characters more than the technical stuff , but another side note : what if Libby is an other and they wanted Claire to remember that stuff for another reason and are her memories even real ?