Originally Posted by queenbeesteph

I think the show has personified the island, made it an entity unto itself. Tom's whole conversation about the island with Michael personifies it. Locke has looked into the "eye" of the island which personified it, etc... I see nothing wrong with personifying the island. Plus the whole show is also about relativism. Everyone has both right and wrong, dark and light, good and evil, in their lives. So we, as the audience, have to consider the show in reference to our own beliefs. This whole Lost site is nothing more than everyone's opinions. Don't judge each other too harshly - it could come back on you. You two need to play nicely...

Sidenote to Flaneuse: You are either right or not right about tautologies. *giggle*