island location - Page 3

Quote:

Originally Posted by benmer007

I like the prop idea. Its more feasible they flew her in on a plane that lands in the water and put her in the Parked Sub ...

.. (Locke) probable saw it was a prop and dove in to check that its propellars didnt exist. When he sees it isnt real he blows it up anyway, to start some civil unrest among Henry's people. That way he is still in control of whats going on.

COME ON! You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about, that is such 100% pure speculation. That theory has so little evidence behind it, and so MUCH evidence against it, that it doesn't even deserve to be recognised.

Quote:

Originally Posted by folie a deux

This is when Colleen was shot by Sun on Desmond's boat. The sub was given as the explanation for how the others got on Des's boat without Jin and Sayid seeing them.

A very very good point.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Integrated

COME ON! You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about, that is such 100% pure speculation. That theory has so little evidence behind it, and so MUCH evidence against it, that it doesn't even deserve to be recognised.

I kind of thought one of the purposes of a forum like this is to throw around any and every idea we can think of; that's part of the fun of it! I love hearing about the many theories everyone thinks up. Just talking about the most likely ideas wouldn't be nearly as entertaining.

Kudos on a statement well said Logan! I've also heard a buzz that the sub we've seen and the "Galaga" might not be the same sub. They've never been completely linked as one and the same. So, like Ben having more than one boat (the one he gave to Michael and the one post-surgery Jack rides on) there might be more than one sub!