Rating for "One of Us"

Please rate the most recent episode "One of Us". Was it good or bad? Worst or Best? You tell me.

Also, please tell us why you voted the way you did, why was this one special or not? Favorite scenes, least favorite, why did you vote the way you did?

Okay, the first half hour was boring and slow, at least for me. But the second half hour was grand and brilliant. Except for the review of everything that happened before, yeah we know...Don't need to show us again.

I really liked it but I don't want to say anything about it until tomorrow when most people should have been able to see it!!! I really liked it though, some small answers...

i really liked it!

it gave a nicer understanding to everything going on in the island and aaah it really was just *thrilling* to watch.

I agree with lostlove . . . I really liked it too. We know a little more about Mikhail and his role, we know the real reason why Juliet is on the island (at least we think we know), and we definitely know where her allegiances lie. Great episode! Kudos to the Lost writers for an exciting second half of season 3!

I voted very good. The reveal at the end was areally good cliff hanger for next week.

I agree with Toad ^^
Only thing I didn't like was the wasted screen time with clips from old episodes. Us diehards didn't need the review.

Very Good in my book. I can get bored with the recaps, however....in this case I think they helped us to get a good idea of the time line of certain events. Also, I think we needed to see some of the recaps in a new light due to new info.

I gave it a 'pretty good'. It was better than last week, but the first half hour was a bit slow.

Favorite scene: the last one between Ben and Juliet.

Favorite quote: Sawyer, as he's walking by Charlie and Hurley; 'there's three men and a baby. I counted Hugo twice. What? I used your real name, Hugo'

Quote:

Originally Posted by Herman

...and we definitely know where her allegiances lie...

But do we really know? We think we do, but as with all things Lost, you never know. It could be that Ben, being the master manipulator, used the threat of banishment to convince Juliet to do what he wants. "We are starting not to like you, Julie, but if you agree in infiltrate their camp, you may be able to redeem yourself in our eyes."

I'm not totally forgiving Julie; I'm just hoping that she's got some other ideas of her own, and plans to double-cross Ben at some point. She seemed like a decent person before the island; I find it hard to accept that she's totally evil now.

I thought it was pretty good. I mean you get to see more into Juliet's character and learn more about the other's motives which was good. But then after learning more about her and sympathizing with her, its suddenly stripped away from you. Like oops nope shes still a plant and working for Ben and shes going to screw everyone over. But overall pretty good.