Do you think Juliet's really allowed to go?

I wish I could read lips upside down. Do you think she's really allowed to leave? I was thinking that the Others knew they would need a doctor around in case of medical emergency so they were forcing her to stay (although initially, she was a willing participant). Now that they have Jack, she's allowed to leave.

I'm sure there are more strings attached than just "Help Sawyer and Kate escape so Jack can fix me and then you can leave". I would think Ben would not give her up that easily.

I think Juliet is crucial to the others, but not because of any medical knowledge...she really couldn't even stitch Ben up. I think they desperately need her because of her fertility research. I am still hanging with the theory that they are from the future where they have accidently rendered themselves sterile in the quest for bio engineered perfection. That is why they asked her to look at the womb of the 26 year old woman, they need her to find out how to correct the problem their genetic engineering has created.

I like the theory Frog, except I thought It is supposed to be less sifi than that.. I don't think they are from the future but I do think that the reason Juliet is there is for the fertility research. I'm assuming and that is all it is that the womb of the 26 year old is on the island or was at one time

Who there is 26/or was at that time?

Not sure... We don't even know how many "others" or "others captives" there are... Gonna have to wait for more answers or see more others to figure that out...

And back on subject:

I don't think Juliet is going anywhere for a while... Technically Jack & Juliet would be free to go if what she said is true and if Mr Linus lives up to his word. (he has lived up to his word before)

I think this time is different because Jack tried and did take the upper had & Mr. Linus knows Juliet was trying to have him killed.. That would be the reason I think he would go back on letting them go "home"

02:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frogmeister

I think Juliet is crucial to the others, but not because of any medical knowledge...she really couldn't even stitch Ben up. I think they desperately need her because of her fertility research. I am still hanging with the theory that they are from the future where they have accidently rendered themselves sterile in the quest for bio engineered perfection. That is why they asked her to look at the womb of the 26 year old woman, they need her to find out how to correct the problem their genetic engineering has created.

Yes. makes sense.... and the book that Aldo was reading outside of Carl's cell... was a brief history of time. it deals with worm holes black holes and multidemensional applications of time and space.

I dont think juliet is allowed to go. and i also dont think she told jack the truth. more plots schemes and ruses.

booyashaka

The bargain was probably to save his own life. Plus, there's gotta be more to what Ben said than we know.

In a word, NO. Jack is a spinal surgeon. Sure he can handle other problems like wounds and rashes. Fertility is a very specialized field. After 10 years of trying to get pregers myself, I have seen may specialists. Each of them focused in a different, unque part of the feild. If you need kids, Juliette is to valuable to just let go.