Two Cities, Two Islands?

As you most likely saw, near the begining of this very exciting season 3 premeire, Oceanic Flight 815 appeared to crash on an island..Next to another island..2 Islands? Ohh Snap!

So, why do you think the losties never discovered the second island? Do you think its hidden in some way? Or was it sheer carelesness that shielded from the sigh of a second Island? All of this time, and no one ever saw the massive island nextdoor, truly a tale of two cities.

By the way, W00t season 3 has started!

Toad, I'm not sure that is right. I think it is the same island, because Henry(Ben), tells Ethan and Goodwin, that they can hike there in a couple of hours. It looked obivious though that "Othersville"was a very secluded portion of the island. And I think that this island maybe a hole lot larger that any of may have previously thought.

Your probaly right, but I like the idea of there being 2 islands. Man, waiting for answers is annoying.

i thought it was the same island, too. he did say that he could make it in one hour if he ran.

(first post in a LONG while...welcome back LOST!!!!)

I do agree in thinking it was only one island. I can't remember if i saw it on this forum or another one that showed a screen shot of the French Woman's island map. It would appear to me as if the island is in fact HUGE...and shapped in such a way for it to maybe look like two islands.

But i do agree...two would be NUTS!

The pod cast said the title was because of 2 communities...

There is only 1 Island

Yeah, I kind of abandoned the 2 island deal after I posted this and watched the episode a second time..So you all can stop telling me how wrong I was..Heh..

But we like to and it's so seldom that we get to do it

Haw haw.

i don't think that there are 2 islands... they must realize it if there are 2