Pip, who started the killings and/or kidnappings, assaults?

I think the Losties did theirs in response.

you listed all those deaths as cold blooded murder.

I would beg to differ with you, though. Not all homicides are murders, and certainly not "cold blooded murder".

Charlie--- Ethan.... debatable, but since he deserved it and there are no jails AND ethan had already committed attempted murder along with kidnapping, I can't say it was coldblooded murder. Besides it was way cool. Charlie's "greatest hit." lol.

Hurley's homicide.... definitely not murder. It was too cool and funny to be called murder. Besides, it was a necessary killing.

all the beach killings..... they didn't ask for the others to hatch a plan to kidnap their women for God only knows what reasons. If I was to find out someone was coming to kidnap my wife and daughter, I'd lay a trap too and kill every one of them. these were justifyable homicides.

Sawyer killing Locke's Dad he had it coming. for a long time. he earned it. he deserved it. and sawyer delivered it. again, no jail. he was guilty of murder back in America, he could never be trusted if he wasn't killed, and it needed to be done.
Besides, it was one of the most anticipated, satisfying moments on the show for me when Sawyer choked the life out of him.

Sawyer's killing of others- they all got it coming.


It will be bittersweet when the master of disaster Ben dies. I'm not sure who I want it to be that kills him. I can just taste his death. hope he suffers. hope he knows its coming and tries to wiggle out of it.

remember in A View to a Kill when Zorin is slipping off the Golden Gate Bridge and he realizes he is about to die? he gives one more twisted chuckle before falling to his death.

I want Ben to get one more twisted, psychotic opportunity to freak out the Losties (and us) just before he dies. but, once he is gone, I will miss him like a family member.

*****
of course, if we find out that Ben and Company really "are the good guys", then I have to rethink all of this........ except for Sawyer choking to death Locke's dad. that was purely awesome.