Originally Posted by L*H

I really like your theory. It all seems to work and the little clues throughout could really support the theory. I wonder what it is about these certain people to put them there on the island. There's that weird thing about Claire's son being the cause of some major disaster. I wonder if it comes to be true. The show has killed off all the people who weren't supposed to be on the island. Boone and Shannon feel appreciative when they realize their lives were saved by being bumped from first class on the plane only to both end up dying. Same with Charlie and all the new cast members from season 2 who came from the other part of the plane. Except of course Bernard who wasn't supposed to be in that part of the plane anyway.