Yeah, I like the theroy chickenpotpie. To go a step further maybe Libby had regretted what she had done, sending desmond away from the one woman he loved. Then Penny's father decides "well I've got to be rid of her too" and books her a ticket on ol' flight 815. I've got a question chickenpotpie do you think everybody on the plane was tricked to be on that flight by penny's father or the other heads of businuess i.e. paik, hanso and so on?