Two shot, and one dead. Who lives?

It sure seems to me in the preview that Kate said, "She's dead." I did not hear anyone say, "They're dead."

It could be premature to be saying that two people were killed.

My Daughter is praying AL lives

Quote:

Originally Posted by RUmooningme

It sure seems to me in the preview that Kate said, "She's dead." I did not hear anyone say, "They're dead."

It could be premature to be saying that two people were killed.

They both have to die. Otherwise they could ID Michael as the shooter.

Saying "she's dead" could mean anything - maybe one is obviously dead, the other isnt...maybe Kate only sees one at first....maybe one dies after medical care...

After having a chance to sleep on it. I now am convinced that Henry took Libby! She will be proven to be an Other.
That is why Kate said, "She's, dead."
Libby is (or was) an Other.

The preview for next week showed Kate saying "she's dead", but it also showed arms being folder over a body that had dark hair.

Sayonara, AnnaLucia. I rather liked her character. However, being as how both of those two ladies have gotten into a sticky point with the law recently, I was fairly certain they would both be leaving the show shortly. Little did I know HOW?!?!?

michael shot himself in the arm so that it looked like henry did it and not him. I think that michael has been brainwashed by the others to free henry for michael. what do you think!

they both have to die.
libby is not an other, or else michael would have been informed this and she would have helped henry escape.

Libby is an Other... that's why she was in the psycho ward with Hurley. But she looked wasted, which could have been medicine, but likely was an act.

Hurley could be the key to this whole thing, as others have speculated, and that would be why Libby LIKES him... b/c he's some kind of HERO to the Others!

Libby might be an other. The look on Michael face could have been shock that he accidently shot an "other"

Quote:

Originally Posted by swjm

michael shot himself in the arm so that it looked like henry did it and not him. I think that michael has been brainwashed by the others to free henry for michael. what do you think!

i agree with you that michael shot himself in the arm to make look like henry did it and not him. i think he did because the others told him that was the only he could get walt back was if he let henry out.