I can't call it the best for the season I haven't seen them all. I will say WOW!!! J.J. will rip your heart out without blinking. It was a FREAKIN" roller coaster ride. I LOVED IT!!!!

__________________
Hope is a very dangerous thing to lose. - Sayid

I do what my Rice Krispies tell me to. - Anonymous

I thought the ending was one of the greatest shockers of all time. However I just can't vote episode of the year. I never seen it coming!

First ep of the year that made me go:

"WHAT the &%^*&%^*&!"

I voted bad. I thought it was pretty cheap to write up Michael suddenly going postal. As if the writers were suddenly thinking "how can we get rid of these two characters." These characters dying becomes even more lame when they have flashbacks for them still and it really doesn't seem to answer anything. Which makes me wonder if any flashbacks will answer anything or if certain characters are so important that they're guaranteed to not die because they're crucial to the story. Deaths like Arzt and Boone were good because they were either expected or amusing and shocking without affecting the threads of the story. But when a character dies, that thread is gone. I have nothing against characters dying, as long as they're not someone I like, I just think everyone getting shot is pretty lame.

And the whole episode revolved around a character who was going to die, so it makes everything that involved her pretty worthless and set up things that might end up making good episodes later on. I can think of a million betters ways to have done it, but instead they went for cheap shock with no substance and I just can't call that good. Oh well, while they're at it, I hope they get started on this war or with some deadly sickness and kill off a few more unimportant people.

Ironically, I've wanted the tailies to die for a while, except for Eko, because they just seemed to take time away from the original cast and I just didn't care about them. But it seems next season there will be even less episodes focused on the original cast and more focused on other survivors, according to the Lost podcast.

Well Im not sure that Libby is dead, two shots to the abdomen would probaly kill you but, maybe the Island will heal her...Or Dr.Jack.

__________________

I thought this was one of the best. As my coworker said this morning "A-maze-ing!"

My husband had to quiet me down after the show's end...I kept going "No!" and holding my hands up on my face. WTF?

__________________

I hope she's not dead. If they get her out of the hatch - according to theory,get her out on the island, and dr jack works his magic then maybe two belly wounds may not kill a young healthy person. But, I've heard that the actress that plays Libby has already signed a contract to be in a sitcom next season - so... I think those bullets were killers.

__________________
katsue

katsuemalibu
Still stuffing my
carryon under the
seat in front
of me.

She's dead. I think people are putting too much stock in the island's magical healing abilities. I didn't see Boone getting healed when he languished for a day before finally giving up.

I gave it best of the season only because with episodes so far apart it's really been hard to remember the last good one. This was a shocker although not surprising. I gues we all know what happens when you get arrested for drunk driving!!. In many ways, it makes sense. AL didn't kill Henry, thus making that character change (like Boone and Shannon) so it was time for her to die. Libby, not sure that she is dead yet. As soon as she comes clean with Hurley about who she really is then she'll bite it.