Rating for "Dave"

Please rate the most recent episode "Dave". Was it good or bad? Worst or Best? You tell me.

Also, please tell us why you voted the way you did, why was this one special or not? Favorite scenes, least favorite, why did you vote the way you did?

wow that was really bad. we learned nothing else about the plot. the only thing we came up with was that it is possible that nothing really exists.

I really liked tonights episode, I connect well with Hurly on certain aspects so I like seeing the episodes about him.

Finding out why Hurley was "Crazy" was a good time, I knew from the point where Dave first mentioned food that he was part of Hurleys imagination. Dave was a very in-depth vision, scares me to think that things could have been that bad for me.

So I rated this one as Good.

my theory was wrong...I thought she was going to push him...sigh

I also think that Libby still has something to hide. I'm sure we'll hear more about her relationship with Hurley, on and off the island.

I think this is the best episode in season 2 . the main reason is b/c I really get into the characters and see this as an important part as to how each of their past lives do play an important part in the whole picture ... Hurley 's past proves that .... To me the real question is why are they all there and to what end .... the connections have not all been revealed , only hinted at so far.

this episode was very wierd to think that it all maybe made up. Does anyone think Libby knows that she was with Hurly????

i really cant stand hurley, so i really didnt enjoy it.

i was hoping more for henry gale.

Can we believe anything "Henry" says at this point? If this were some sort of experiment wouldn't he tell Locke something to keep him pushing the button, rather than telling him nothing happens when it isn't pushed? However, how could he know about what happens with the counter unless he was part of the experiment or at least knew about it.

I thought it was good, but not the best. I did feel like I connected with Hurley, too. As a chubby girl, I know how he feels with worrying no one will find him attractive. And how I tend to eat even when I'm not hungry.

I was worried for a bit that Hurley WAS imagining everything...but the writers promised no dream cop-out. I just wonder if Libby is good or evil, but their kiss was so cute - way better than Kate and Jack's kiss.