Quote:
Originally Posted by queenbeesteph
So apparently Alex has some questions about Ben? Does Carl have the answers? Why would she even suspect that Ben was not her father?
|
Yeah, Carl did give a look like he might have some answers.
I had a crazy idea. Going along with the theory that Richard and the hostiles arrived on the island via the Black Rock. What if Carl was originally a hostile too. Maybe he was the cabin boy on the Black Rock and hasn't aged like Richard.
Or is that just too weird cause then Carl would have seen Alex grow up and now they are boyfriend/girlfriend......