Well I think certain people are supposed to die. I mean as Locke said Boone was supposed to be a "sacrifice" for the island. Why Was Ecko taken? Also it seems that anyone who dies from gun shot is def. dead. Shannon, Ana Lucia, Libbie, the girl Sun shot and the dude Juliet shot. Guns do seem to have a clear/cut death warrant attached to them, but death in other ways can sometimes be iffy or not final. hmmmmmmmm

__________________
Because all we really need to survive is one person who truly loves us. And you have her.