I thought of another problem with the possibility of the sub being fake. In eppy 3-04 EMFH Ben busts in on Juliet and Jack in the aquarium cell and says:
Quote:
|
The sub is back. We have a situation. So come with me now.
|
This is when Colleen was shot by Sun on Desmond's boat. The sub was given as the explanation for how the others got on Des's boat without Jin and Sayid seeing them.
So if the sub is fake and all this is just a ruse, then.... damn. That just doesn't add up IMO.