But do we really know? We think we do, but as with all things Lost, you never know. It could be that Ben, being the master manipulator, used the threat of banishment to convince Juliet to do what he wants. "We are starting not to like you, Julie, but if you agree in infiltrate their camp, you may be able to redeem yourself in our eyes."

I'm not totally forgiving Julie; I'm just hoping that she's got some other ideas of her own, and plans to double-cross Ben at some point. She seemed like a decent person before the island; I find it hard to accept that she's totally evil now.