Originally Posted by benmer007

So we get revealed in this episode that sawyer and kate probably wont work out.

This is my opinion and i have the following to back it up:

1- Kate calls sawyer James. shes calling him by the name his mother used to. This means shes sick of his tail between his legs attitude. Jack literally gave his life for thiers, and thats the type of man she needs.
2- Carl in that scene is like thier kid. Hes obviously a simpleton and has the cognitive abilities of somenoe half his age. With him ( aka a child ) in the equation. it is apparent that kate and sawyer cant ge along ( or raise one of thier own together ).
3- Sawyer and kate would have done different things with carl. they arent as similar as we thought.
4- If kate did/ does love saywer... he is not the only one she loves and he ruined that by assuming her reasons for sleeping with him. Assuming it was out of pity or something. Ths type of behaviour usually gets men in trouble with thier women.

Originally Posted by benmer007

What yall think? I know i am biased about wanting kate and jack back together... but i made notes this morn as i watched the dynamic and i dont see it working out. i give it a Highly Unlikely