Originally Posted by queenbeesteph

Frogmeister - I saw that podcast conformation on it not being a dream, too. But I don't think it will keep looping the same, because we already know this time around and the first(?) time around are bits&pieces different....e.i. Desmond doesn't buy the ring, but changes his mind and walks out, 2nd time takes the ring but throws it in the water. I think Desmond's best mate said a VERY key thing right when they first introduced him (after commercial). He was talking to a lady about you could do the same thing ten times and end up with ten different outcomes. I think this is going to be significant. btw - it might also help explain why penny was in a white shirt in one picture and a black in another; and why in life1 penny and des each had a picture and in life2 there was only one picture, and what Darnzy said about Penny being around in life1 and Charlie being around in life2. Could this also mean that who he was supposed to save has changed? Penny in life1, but now it's Charlie?