I don't trust anything any of the others say - including weepy, soft-spoken Juliette (who will turn around and shoot someone without even blinking). Did Ben say that he had been on the island his whole life? Did Rousseau say that she had been pregnant when she and the 5 others were on their scientific expedition? So IF I believe either one of those two Ben couldn't be her bio dad... UNLESS he took a sabatical and left the island for a little while and met Danielle right before she left to go on her scientific expedition.

__________________