From the first season....

I remember hurly and the boys looking for high ground to find the radio signal. I also remember from last season desmond following the old hatch guy back to his boat around the island. Also they found the pirate ship around another side of the island... and then how far around the island did sayid and them go becuase logically after you come around half of the island you should be abble to see the other one...

point being they never saw this other island at those points...


henry Gale says his one island is about twice the size of Alcatraz...

well let me tell you alcatraz is small. I think he's lying yet again...

and more importantly He's been on the island all his life... how would he have any idea about the size of alcatraz... and seeing something about it on tv wouldnt do it.

more lies... it was probably a mirage... they did shoot sawyer up with hallucinagins...