Originally Posted by charlie98210

Not a false memory, but more like no memory. When he arrived on the beach, Charlie takes a moment to look wonderingly at his burned forearms. Then he says, when asked where Locke and Eko are, "Haven't they already come back?" or something to that affect.

He's probably got a touch of shock or a concussion, that'll mess up your reactions, big time.

ps, after the hatch door hit, I was waiting for Locke or Eko to "drop" in...

(I know, but I have a sick sense of humor sometimes).